If you only visited Aspen during ski season, you might be forgiven for thinking the place is snowy all year round. Similarly, a third grader might well imagine his teacher lives at school, since that’s the only place he ever sees her. Any time a periodic observation is synchronized with the event it measures, things get screwy. This movie makes the problem clear.
No matter how surreal it looks, this helicopter isn’t doing anything strange. The rotor turns at a certain rate, and the camera happens to be snapping frames for the movie at exactly the same rate (or a multiple of the same rate, but that complicates the explanation). So the camera is catching the rotor blades at exactly the point as they whirl around. As a result they look like they’re motionless. But if you were on the ground watching, nothing would look amiss.
Here’s another instructive video of a more prosaic system: the wheel of a bike.
A notable application of this kind of synchronization was the Red Baron’s machine gun. In World War I, if you mounted the guns where they were most conveniently operated by the pilot (just over the nose of the plane), you had the unfortunate side effect of shooting off your propeller. The first solution to this problem, introduced in 1914 by Saulmier, was to use armored blades, so bullets did minimal damage when, inevitably, they struck the prop. But the cleverer solution by far was strobing: use an interrupter gear that only lets the machine gun operate when the prop is safely out of the way. Just as with the helicopter video, from the gun’s point of view, the propeller is motionless.
4 thoughts on “Helicopter strobing”
I remember getting an early explanation of this phenomenon from my dad when I would sit on the floor of our kitchen spinning one of those suction cup push tops for toddlers. The kitchen had an awful circular florescent bulb that strobed around 60hz. I loved sitting there watching it slow, stop, spin backwards. An experience my kids won’t get with our fancy halogen lighting…
Wikipedia calls this “temporal aliasing” which sounds like one of the abilities found on Heroes.
Btw – Saulmier’s solution really sounds like a problem. I wonder how many pilots died from their own ricochets?
Halogen lights have some tricks of their own. For instance, you can show the girls how, if you hold a paper napkin up against the bulb, it bursts into bright flames in less than ten seconds. And that’s just a prelude to the “turtle in a microwave” science lesson.
Incidentally, ricochets were the least of Saulmier’s troubles. The life expectancy of a fighter pilot in World War I was about five and a half minutes, so you were doing pretty well just to have the ricochet problem.
Regarding the heliocopter in the video, I had expected the changes in rotor pitch to be more pronounced through the various turns and hovers, but I had to watch the video a few times to really appreciate the subtle changes. Not at all like the animations from “How to do it.”
That reminds me of watching the ailerons on an airplane. It take very little variation to make the plane roll appreciably. That helicopter rotor is spinning so fast that a tiny change in pitch makes a big different in lift.
Comments are closed.